{"format":"hypgraph/1-bundle","generator":"hypgraph 0.7.18","exported_at":"2026-11-01T00:55:31+00:00","complete":true,"redacted_events":0,"scope":{"inv":"","title":"whole graph"},"policy":{"reviewers":["whitehead"],"instrument":"lab","operator":"operator","importer":"importer","system":"system","max_creates_per_minute":60,"extra_reserved":[]},"head":"0d984abea832785c22f8c34808cf1c015c21caae3bd39ffcdd45615859e7efff","events":[{"seq":1,"hash":"8aee2b431643fd8e9361cc1bcb2c0eea3e912f2de6666051b5e0733fcfff744d","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"1da652c6f241514536f4d0a669b1a0dc53fc056413b8ef826672f8e05caf3b2d\",\"code\":\"INV1\",\"inv\":\"\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"investigation\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"ref\":\"inv-a73f34e7\"}"},{"seq":2,"hash":"f94d4c1d4c129ba67dcc1380e1cc62080b8d0c55b3390bbc15efd736396669a0","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"0376cb45e7f7324a05d702a9e2fa04686433e6a923b33e30bc17c1116c9aaee9\",\"code\":\"Q1\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"question\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"8aee2b431643fd8e9361cc1bcb2c0eea3e912f2de6666051b5e0733fcfff744d\",\"ref\":\"n89fe7c887b89\"}"},{"seq":3,"hash":"b65cc9af2125d4f13b5e23b32cf4a5435a11ae409530f6372d99bf70d0915d9c","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"56e91d011a903c818e6cbff7e1dc794f799756c13bd79bb2d5bbb0b016d8d1b6\",\"code\":\"S1\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"source\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"f94d4c1d4c129ba67dcc1380e1cc62080b8d0c55b3390bbc15efd736396669a0\",\"ref\":\"n428c0b0ad05b\"}"},{"seq":4,"hash":"d30f9369d9b10dece983957da6163f08c6e8d2708c62f910abcb5675b2f113df","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"ef68d464f97fff35c93661832bbcaf5e9bff01d1a3c02843885d0150de16f81e\",\"code\":\"S2\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"source\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"b65cc9af2125d4f13b5e23b32cf4a5435a11ae409530f6372d99bf70d0915d9c\",\"ref\":\"n67164f698148\"}"},{"seq":5,"hash":"ada197ac51451c377c187fc98fe542f616642de0a285c08d3e766ff9581bee24","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"d6b591b45c3ff7ec4f59daa8d728e359017bd2f9aabf5eff444692e9ca0c12ba\",\"code\":\"S3\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"source\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"d30f9369d9b10dece983957da6163f08c6e8d2708c62f910abcb5675b2f113df\",\"ref\":\"ne92351ca86f8\"}"},{"seq":6,"hash":"f9f62ca09ddceb347e71ca9865dd056184ca29619b9bb7d90b23445e2d46752c","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"afb17557b1ce2a4e65e8702843df35158f8959fa37f4832e2dde58fccd6ee500\",\"code\":\"H1\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"hypothesis\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"ada197ac51451c377c187fc98fe542f616642de0a285c08d3e766ff9581bee24\",\"ref\":\"nd1651cf74134\"}"},{"seq":7,"hash":"1fd0ebe4278245b168e73edebdea6ff6e2e388adc47a6195afe7c9c091ca1a05","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n89fe7c887b89\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":1,\"rel\":\"answers\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\"},\"prev\":\"f9f62ca09ddceb347e71ca9865dd056184ca29619b9bb7d90b23445e2d46752c\",\"ref\":\"nd1651cf74134\"}"},{"seq":8,"hash":"5651d373fc1be6869a1ca0ed88d0ecc208cf7a4be90f2d86b6d63f5c690379a0","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"0f384d3a67cbd23983aad93268a1d80b63527e5fc41398281063e142e74e962e\",\"code\":\"CL1\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"claim\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"1fd0ebe4278245b168e73edebdea6ff6e2e388adc47a6195afe7c9c091ca1a05\",\"ref\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\"}"},{"seq":9,"hash":"8813d58aed5445a157aae60333370ff2f4bebfe64d576e6f241425bf36a19a7d","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n89fe7c887b89\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":2,\"rel\":\"answers\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\"},\"prev\":\"5651d373fc1be6869a1ca0ed88d0ecc208cf7a4be90f2d86b6d63f5c690379a0\",\"ref\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\"}"},{"seq":10,"hash":"6a60bd96aeadeabd9a2b506d996818b9699f930e5955abc5cd42db4b2f6decfc","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":3,\"rel\":\"supports\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"7e088bca8ed55c586ea25f9779ce4e53eb90364decadf1b62da3cb548115466f\"},\"prev\":\"8813d58aed5445a157aae60333370ff2f4bebfe64d576e6f241425bf36a19a7d\",\"ref\":\"n428c0b0ad05b\"}"},{"seq":11,"hash":"f6a31aff2af7185f467f7eb03239cbaaad0e421e049820277a943dbfd8b03a2d","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":4,\"rel\":\"supports\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"13546577256b9a7712b74926938e49d4718ddb20f783a1403353e4787e9902b2\"},\"prev\":\"6a60bd96aeadeabd9a2b506d996818b9699f930e5955abc5cd42db4b2f6decfc\",\"ref\":\"n67164f698148\"}"},{"seq":12,"hash":"bcb30fb6ec168ef8602fb12de91ff21fa678e45eb404369a8a735385b02afdb2","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":5,\"rel\":\"supports\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"2090cfc30766ef42cdf69cc929efae62c8815feb7652fb496bc5325e8092ae7b\"},\"prev\":\"f6a31aff2af7185f467f7eb03239cbaaad0e421e049820277a943dbfd8b03a2d\",\"ref\":\"ne92351ca86f8\"}"},{"seq":13,"hash":"c3c7f41525ab61a05aadea8d1b75681a95bd00987b237eb72f41ba85a006af8c","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"create\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"f965ff5879e9b0e3a550d5e37f32ba17a8b1e3c0d2e14b471566d5c93be9b290\",\"code\":\"RS1\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"reason_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\",\"type\":\"result\",\"v\":1},\"prev\":\"bcb30fb6ec168ef8602fb12de91ff21fa678e45eb404369a8a735385b02afdb2\",\"ref\":\"n7814c683cc48\"}"},{"seq":14,"hash":"9c36c7dba1cd09a3e28e76544da7169174bad53edff59a9b33b10cdda8ac917f","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n67164f698148\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":6,\"rel\":\"derived_from\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\"},\"prev\":\"c3c7f41525ab61a05aadea8d1b75681a95bd00987b237eb72f41ba85a006af8c\",\"ref\":\"n7814c683cc48\"}"},{"seq":15,"hash":"df8aa29634e115a18b6653f0aae072c9fc9d83e5498ede26e7c75da4ec56dd5b","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"ne92351ca86f8\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":7,\"rel\":\"derived_from\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\"},\"prev\":\"9c36c7dba1cd09a3e28e76544da7169174bad53edff59a9b33b10cdda8ac917f\",\"ref\":\"n7814c683cc48\"}"},{"seq":16,"hash":"645ece130311938d0ede9d30db0a507110b536ae3ea2767cd7d9b544203a8ae9","body":"{\"actor\":\"you\",\"at\":\"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"nd1651cf74134\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":8,\"rel\":\"supports\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"8b2398c0f95cfaf8bdec0d9cbbb8afb9a21a065042222dc3e0653581ba4b70cc\"},\"prev\":\"df8aa29634e115a18b6653f0aae072c9fc9d83e5498ede26e7c75da4ec56dd5b\",\"ref\":\"n7814c683cc48\"}"},{"seq":17,"hash":"e8696025569bcb0cf287f5f2a1a2a5a41151d0acd101cad1335127b09d27e2ab","body":"{\"actor\":\"whitehead\",\"at\":\"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"review\",\"payload\":{\"body_sha\":\"b105d5bb1d9c322d669ccf431f435437e6b9636f0c55b20ff911391809e41494\",\"code\":\"RV1\",\"inv\":\"inv-a73f34e7\",\"official\":true,\"on_v\":1,\"review\":\"ne747339df24b\",\"verdict\":\"checked\"},\"prev\":\"645ece130311938d0ede9d30db0a507110b536ae3ea2767cd7d9b544203a8ae9\",\"ref\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\"}"},{"seq":18,"hash":"0d984abea832785c22f8c34808cf1c015c21caae3bd39ffcdd45615859e7efff","body":"{\"actor\":\"whitehead\",\"at\":\"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00\",\"kind\":\"link\",\"payload\":{\"data_sha\":\"44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a\",\"dst\":\"n3e553a3adcbd\",\"dst_v\":1,\"edge\":9,\"rel\":\"reviews\",\"src_v\":1,\"why_sha\":\"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855\"},\"prev\":\"e8696025569bcb0cf287f5f2a1a2a5a41151d0acd101cad1335127b09d27e2ab\",\"ref\":\"ne747339df24b\"}"}],"nodes":[{"id":"inv-a73f34e7","type":"investigation","code":"INV1","inv":"","created_at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"n89fe7c887b89","type":"question","code":"Q1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"n428c0b0ad05b","type":"source","code":"S1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"n67164f698148","type":"source","code":"S2","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"ne92351ca86f8","type":"source","code":"S3","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"nd1651cf74134","type":"hypothesis","code":"H1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"n3e553a3adcbd","type":"claim","code":"CL1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"n7814c683cc48","type":"result","code":"RS1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"you"},{"id":"ne747339df24b","type":"review","code":"RV1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","created_at":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00","created_by":"whitehead"}],"versions":[{"node":"inv-a73f34e7","v":1,"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"objective\":\"Ask whether the 1854 finding, that cholera travels in water, held when it was tested again in a later epidemic, using the two records that tested it.\",\"reviewers\":[\"whitehead\"],\"scope\":\"The Broad Street record (1854) and the East London record (1866), each cited by pinned reference: this record holds neither's evidence, only what each said.\",\"success_criteria\":\"Both records' findings stand as pinned, and the later one tests the earlier one's prediction.\",\"title\":\"London's water, 1854–1866: did the finding hold?\"}"},{"node":"n89fe7c887b89","v":1,"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"text\":\"Did the 1854 finding hold in a later epidemic?\",\"why\":\"One epidemic can mislead; a finding that predicts the next one is worth more.\"}"},{"node":"n428c0b0ad05b","v":1,"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"citation\":\"CL1 (claim) in https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street, version 2: The Golden Square outbreak was spread by water from the Broad Street pump: those who drank it died, while 5 of the 535 workhouse inmates, who had their own well, died.\",\"hash\":\"7983bcb28bbed44d09e837f0ac0df5b5d9e46d4367702e254b47cf10b360d07e\",\"kind\":\"primary\",\"node\":\"n10be66290f89\",\"record\":\"https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street\",\"reliability\":\"The Golden Square outbreak, replicated by a skeptic on new data.\",\"retrieved\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00Z\",\"says\":\"The Golden Square outbreak was spread by water from the Broad Street pump: those who drank it died, while 5 of the 535 workhouse inmates, who had their own well, died.\",\"url\":\"https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street/#node=n10be66290f89\",\"version\":2}"},{"node":"n67164f698148","v":1,"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"citation\":\"CL2 (claim) in https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street, version 1: Houses supplied by the Southwark and Vauxhall Company had 315 cholera deaths per 10,000 houses against 37 for Lambeth — 8.5 times the rate, in the same streets.\",\"hash\":\"a4d6f4bce77267cd4d04ba690a93ccc467035c7b09cd85a4ce79d9865fe5f63f\",\"kind\":\"primary\",\"node\":\"n5973f10d5c54\",\"record\":\"https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street\",\"reliability\":\"The south London comparison: neighbours on different water, 8.5 times the rate.\",\"retrieved\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00Z\",\"says\":\"Houses supplied by the Southwark and Vauxhall Company had 315 cholera deaths per 10,000 houses against 37 for Lambeth — 8.5 times the rate, in the same streets.\",\"url\":\"https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street/#node=n5973f10d5c54\",\"version\":1}"},{"node":"ne92351ca86f8","v":1,"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"citation\":\"CL1 (claim) in https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/east-london-1866, version 1: The 1866 epidemic in east London followed the East London Water Company's supply, as the 1854 comparison of the south London companies did.\",\"hash\":\"4b4b4cadfee3bfeab4f0a7f2240f488b3946320aa8bf012652043c2fd79c0636\",\"kind\":\"primary\",\"node\":\"n1c23bd422b62\",\"record\":\"https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/east-london-1866\",\"reliability\":\"The 1866 epidemic, checked by an independent inquiry for the Privy Council.\",\"retrieved\":\"1867-03-01T10:00:00Z\",\"says\":\"The 1866 epidemic in east London followed the East London Water Company's supply, as the 1854 comparison of the south London companies did.\",\"url\":\"https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/east-london-1866/#node=n1c23bd422b62\",\"version\":1}"},{"node":"nd1651cf74134","v":1,"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"predictions\":[\"A later epidemic follows a contaminated supply, as 1854 did.\"],\"statement\":\"Cholera travels in water: a supply contaminated with sewage spreads it, in any epidemic.\"}"},{"node":"n3e553a3adcbd","v":1,"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"limitations\":\"This record rests on the two others' claims as pinned; if either is revised or withdrawn, the pin says so and this claim should be read again.\",\"scope\":\"London's cholera epidemics of 1854 and 1866, as the two cited records state them.\",\"statement\":\"The 1854 finding held: in 1866 the deaths followed a contaminated supply again, as the comparison of 1854 predicts.\"}"},{"node":"n7814c683cc48","v":1,"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","reason":"","body":"{\"kind\":\"cited\",\"outcome\":\"positive\",\"summary\":\"Both records' findings, as pinned, are what the water hypothesis predicts.\"}"},{"node":"ne747339df24b","v":1,"at":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"whitehead","reason":"","body":"{\"method\":\"Read each pinned claim in its own record.\",\"notes\":\"Both stand as pinned; the 1866 record repeats the comparison my inquiry confirmed.\",\"official\":true,\"verdict\":\"checked\"}"}],"edges":[{"id":1,"src":"nd1651cf74134","src_v":1,"rel":"answers","dst":"n89fe7c887b89","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":2,"src":"n3e553a3adcbd","src_v":1,"rel":"answers","dst":"n89fe7c887b89","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":3,"src":"n428c0b0ad05b","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"The 1854 outbreak followed one pump."},{"id":4,"src":"n67164f698148","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"In 1854 neighbours on different water died at different rates."},{"id":5,"src":"ne92351ca86f8","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"In 1866 the deaths followed one company's water again."},{"id":6,"src":"n7814c683cc48","src_v":1,"rel":"derived_from","dst":"n67164f698148","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":7,"src":"n7814c683cc48","src_v":1,"rel":"derived_from","dst":"ne92351ca86f8","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":8,"src":"n7814c683cc48","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"nd1651cf74134","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"Two epidemics, two companies, one pattern."},{"id":9,"src":"ne747339df24b","src_v":1,"rel":"reviews","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":"{}","at":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"whitehead","why":""}],"withdrawals":[],"retractions":[],"leases":[],"derived":{"investigations":[{"id":"inv-a73f34e7","type":"investigation","code":"INV1","inv":"","title":"London's water, 1854–1866: did the finding hold?","kind":"","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active investigation"},"counts":{"question":1,"source":3,"hypothesis":1,"claim":1,"result":1,"review":1},"body":{"objective":"Ask whether the 1854 finding, that cholera travels in water, held when it was tested again in a later epidemic, using the two records that tested it.","reviewers":["whitehead"],"scope":"The Broad Street record (1854) and the East London record (1866), each cited by pinned reference: this record holds neither's evidence, only what each said.","success_criteria":"Both records' findings stand as pinned, and the later one tests the earlier one's prediction.","title":"London's water, 1854–1866: did the finding hold?"}}],"stats":{"seq":18,"nodes":9,"edges":9,"by_type":{"investigation":1,"question":1,"source":3,"hypothesis":1,"claim":1,"result":1,"review":1},"leases":0},"by_inv":{"inv-a73f34e7":{"subgraph":{"seq":18,"nodes":[{"id":"inv-a73f34e7","type":"investigation","code":"INV1","inv":"","title":"London's water, 1854–1866: did the finding hold?","kind":"","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active investigation"}},{"id":"n89fe7c887b89","type":"question","code":"Q1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"Did the 1854 finding hold in a later epidemic?","kind":"","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active question"}},{"id":"n428c0b0ad05b","type":"source","code":"S1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"CL1 (claim) in https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street, version 2: The Golden Square outbreak was spread by water from the Broad Street pump: those who drank it died, while 5 of the 535 workhouse inmates, who had their own well, died.","kind":"primary","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active source"}},{"id":"n67164f698148","type":"source","code":"S2","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"CL2 (claim) in https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/broad-street, version 1: Houses supplied by the Southwark and Vauxhall Company had 315 cholera deaths per 10,000 houses against 37 for Lambeth — 8.5 times the rate, in the same streets.","kind":"primary","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active source"}},{"id":"ne92351ca86f8","type":"source","code":"S3","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"CL1 (claim) in https://hypgraph.com/examples/linked/east-london-1866, version 1: The 1866 epidemic in east London followed the East London Water Company's supply, as the 1854 comparison of the south London companies did.","kind":"primary","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active source"}},{"id":"nd1651cf74134","type":"hypothesis","code":"H1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"Cholera travels in water: a supply contaminated with sewage spreads it, in any epidemic.","kind":"","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","review":{"state":"unchecked","positive":[],"negative":[],"open_objections":[],"reviews":0,"comments":0},"evidence":"unverified","independent_lines":1,"challenges":0,"unsupported":false,"fallen":false,"sentence":"active hypothesis · unchecked · 1 independent line of support · unverified report · no external replication"}},{"id":"n3e553a3adcbd","type":"claim","code":"CL1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"The 1854 finding held: in 1866 the deaths followed a contaminated supply again, as the comparison of 1854 predicts.","kind":"","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","review":{"state":"checked","positive":["whitehead:checked"],"negative":[],"open_objections":[],"reviews":1,"comments":0},"evidence":"external","independent_lines":3,"challenges":0,"unsupported":false,"fallen":false,"sentence":"active claim · checked (whitehead:checked, v1) · 3 independent lines of support · external source"}},{"id":"n7814c683cc48","type":"result","code":"RS1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"Both records' findings, as pinned, are what the water hypothesis predicts.","kind":"cited","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","review":{"state":"unchecked","positive":[],"negative":[],"open_objections":[],"reviews":0,"comments":0},"outcome":"positive","fallen":false,"sentence":"active result · unchecked · outcome positive"}},{"id":"ne747339df24b","type":"review","code":"RV1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"checked","kind":"checked","v":1,"by":"whitehead","at":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","fallen":false,"sentence":"active review"}}],"edges":[{"id":1,"src":"nd1651cf74134","src_v":1,"rel":"answers","dst":"n89fe7c887b89","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":2,"src":"n3e553a3adcbd","src_v":1,"rel":"answers","dst":"n89fe7c887b89","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":3,"src":"n428c0b0ad05b","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"The 1854 outbreak followed one pump."},{"id":4,"src":"n67164f698148","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"In 1854 neighbours on different water died at different rates."},{"id":5,"src":"ne92351ca86f8","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"In 1866 the deaths followed one company's water again."},{"id":6,"src":"n7814c683cc48","src_v":1,"rel":"derived_from","dst":"n67164f698148","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":7,"src":"n7814c683cc48","src_v":1,"rel":"derived_from","dst":"ne92351ca86f8","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":""},{"id":8,"src":"n7814c683cc48","src_v":1,"rel":"supports","dst":"nd1651cf74134","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-03-15T10:00:00+00:00","by":"you","why":"Two epidemics, two companies, one pattern."},{"id":9,"src":"ne747339df24b","src_v":1,"rel":"reviews","dst":"n3e553a3adcbd","dst_v":1,"data":{},"at":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00","by":"whitehead","why":""}]},"work":{"leases":[],"review_queue":[],"revalidation":[],"contested":[],"decisions_to_revisit":[],"duplicates":[]},"next":{"ranked":[],"untested_hypotheses":[{"id":"nd1651cf74134","type":"hypothesis","code":"H1","inv":"inv-a73f34e7","title":"Cholera travels in water: a supply contaminated with sewage spreads it, in any epidemic.","kind":"","v":1,"by":"you","at":"1867-03-01T10:00:00+00:00","state":{"lifecycle":"active","review":{"state":"unchecked","positive":[],"negative":[],"open_objections":[],"reviews":0,"comments":0},"evidence":"unverified","independent_lines":1,"challenges":0,"unsupported":false,"fallen":false,"sentence":"active hypothesis · unchecked · 1 independent line of support · unverified report · no external replication"}}],"rule":"score = hypotheses it separates (distinct expected outcomes) × 1.5 if it can show its own power ÷ log2(2 + cost in minutes); duplicates and leased work last"},"report":{"inv":"inv-a73f34e7","code":"INV1","title":"London's water, 1854–1866: did the finding hold?","state":"active","objective":"Ask whether the 1854 finding, that cholera travels in water, held when it was tested again in a later epidemic, using the two records that tested it.","claims":[{"id":"n3e553a3adcbd","code":"CL1","type":"claim","title":"The 1854 finding held: in 1866 the deaths followed a contaminated supply again, as the comparison of 1854 predicts.","lifecycle":"active","review":"checked","verdicts":["whitehead: checked (RV1, on v1)"],"v":1,"evidence":"external","lines":3,"stale":[]}],"results":[{"id":"n7814c683cc48","code":"RS1","type":"result","title":"Both records' findings, as pinned, are what the water hypothesis predicts.","outcome":"positive","by":"you","in_a_claim":false,"lifecycle":"active","stale":[]}],"hypotheses":[{"id":"nd1651cf74134","code":"H1","type":"hypothesis","title":"Cholera travels in water: a supply contaminated with sewage spreads it, in any epidemic.","lifecycle":"active","support":1,"challenges":0}],"experiments":[],"open":{"claims_unreviewed":[],"claims_contested":[],"claims_stale":[],"results_in_no_claim":["RS1"],"experiments_not_preregistered":[]},"spend":{"usd":0.0,"calls":0,"reviews":1,"usd_per_verdict":null,"last_moved":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00","metered":false},"seq":18,"markdown":"## Facts from the research graph — INV1 London's water, 1854–1866: did the finding hold? (active)\n_Generated from the record at event 18; do not edit — regenerate it from the graph. Standing is derived by the record's rules, not certified, and none of this is advice (https://hypgraph.com/disclaimer/). Interpretation goes below this section._\n\n### Claims\n\n| claim | standing | review | verdicts | statement |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| CL1 v1 | active | checked | whitehead: checked (RV1, on v1) | The 1854 finding held: in 1866 the deaths followed a contaminated supply again, as the comparison of 1854 predicts. |\n\n### Results\n\n| result | outcome | by | carried by a claim | summary |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| RS1 | positive | you | NO | Both records' findings, as pinned, are what the water hypothesis predicts. |\n\n### Hypotheses\n\n- H1 (active; support lines 1, challenges 0): Cholera travels in water: a supply contaminated with sewage spreads it, in any epidemic.\n\n### Experiments\n\n- none\n\n### Open items\n\n- claims not yet reviewed: none\n- claims contested: none\n- claims on stale evidence (what they rest on has changed since; a check of them no longer counts): none\n- results no claim carries (their conclusions are unreviewed): RS1\n- experiments not preregistered: none"},"profile":{"id":"","name":"","version":0,"about":"","labels":{"investigation":"Investigation","question":"Question","hypothesis":"Hypothesis","claim":"Claim","experiment":"Experiment","run":"Run","result":"Result","artifact":"Artifact","source":"Source","review":"Review","decision":"Decision","task":"Task"},"vocabulary":{},"workflow":null},"stages":[{"question":"n89fe7c887b89","code":"Q1","profile":"","workflow":false,"stage":"","index":0,"of":0,"complete":false,"next":"no workflow: the profile has no stages (pin an @2 profile)","gates":[]}],"completion":{"investigation":"inv-a73f34e7","profile":"scientific@1","pinned":false,"criteria":[{"name":"questions_settled","met":true,"why":"every question is settled by a checked claim"}],"complete":true},"board":[{"id":"n89fe7c887b89","code":"Q1","text":"Did the 1854 finding hold in a later epidemic?","status":"settled","by":"CL1 (checked by whitehead)","answers":["CL1"],"unchecked":[],"unreviewable":[]}],"orders":[]}},"verify":{"ok":true,"checked":18,"head":"0d984abea832785c22f8c34808cf1c015c21caae3bd39ffcdd45615859e7efff","unchecked":{},"coverage":"complete","policy":{"importer":"importer"}},"at":"1867-04-01T10:00:00+00:00"}}